I felt a little disappointed after reading the following article in Times of India the other day:
IITs can't expel students on merit excuse: SC (emphasis mine). The Supreme Court directed IIT Delhi to reconsider its decision to expel 5 students after their grades did not meet the minimum requirements. Although, the SC acknowledged that "the petitioners were not able to secure the required credits as against the stipulated minimum requirement for continuation of their studies”, yet it ordered IIT Delhi to re-enroll the students.
The whole paragraph looks unbelievable until you add the "missing piece"---the students belonged to SC/ST category. Some people would now find the puzzle cohesively complete and argue that the decision was correct. I have been against the dilution of IIT as an institution and as a brand since the
proposed expansion as well as the subsequent
dropping cutoffs in the entrance examination. Reservations are needed and make more sense at the basic levels of education---making primary and secondary school education more accessible and widely available---but should have no place at graduate level where according to me, only merit and performance should prevail. Tripling the number of IITs without any resources and slashing down passing marks to merely 18% for the entrance examination is unjust both towards the IIT system and the students.
Marketing students are taught case studies about
brand dilution of
Pierre Cardin, a popular fashion designer. From the article, the Pierre Cardin name was licensed to appear on over 900 marginal products such as push chairs, olive oil, frying pans, floor tiles, sardines, orthopedic mattresses, socks, ‘Memory' pillows, phone holders, pens, coffee pots and thermoses. Pierre Cardin products were retailing at knock down prices in discount shops and the brand was seen on paraphernalia that detracted from the brand's core values. Pierre Cardin himself, though, defends his licensing position by stating, the €30m profits it generates for him a year aside, that why shouldn't his brand be accessible to everyone? He even adds: "If someone asked me to do toilet paper, I'd do it. Why not?"
It is sad to see IITs being pushed down the same path whereby quantity is promoted over quality and merit is considered an excuse. The IITs were created to train scientists and engineers, with the aim of developing a skilled workforce to support the economic and social development of India---too bad our focus is shifting from skilled to workforce.